Branding Gold or Ideological Gamble?

Ever wondered why you can spot those golden arches from a mile away? Or why the swoosh on your sneakers feels like an old friend? That's the magic of logos, my friends. But here's the thing – while these little symbols pack a punch in the branding world, they're not always the slam dunk you might think. Let's dive into the wild world of logos and unpack why some hit the mark while others... well, let's just say they missed the memo.

Logos: The Unsung Heroes of Branding


Think about it. A tiny image that can make you crave a burger or feel sporty – that's power, right there. Logos are like the face of your brand, the first thing people see at the party. They're working overtime to:

1.    Get you noticed in a sea of sameness

2.    Tell your brand's story without saying a word

3.    Make sure folks remember you (for the right reasons)

4.    Keep your look on point across all your stuff

5.    Show the world you mean business

But here's where it gets tricky. Some folks get a bit carried away and start thinking their logo should be shouting their worldview from the rooftops. Spoiler alert: that's when things can go sideways.

When Logos Go Rogue: The Ideological Oopsie

Picture this: you're a big shot brand, and you decide your logo needs to scream "We're hip! We're with it! We have opinions!" Sounds great in theory, right? Well, not so fast. This is where brands can stumble into what I like to call the "ideological oopsie." Here's why it's a slippery slope:

1.    You might accidentally give half your customers the cold shoulder

2.    Your logo could age faster than that milk in the back of your fridge

3.    Different folks might read your logo in ways you never saw coming

4.    Your actual product gets lost in the sauce of your logo's message

5.    You box yourself in, making it tough to branch out later

Let me tell you a story that'll make you cringe (in a good way, promise).

The Gap-tastrophe of 2010

Remember Gap? Of course you do. Blue square, white letters, classic. Well, back in 2010, someone at Gap HQ must've thought - "You know what we need? A total logo makeover!" And boy, did they go for it.


They swapped out their iconic blue square for... wait for it... a tiny blue square. Groundbreaking, right? The new logo had "Gap" in a plain font with this little blue square peeking out behind the 'p' like it was playing hide and seek.

The idea : They wanted to look modern and ‘hip’. In reality, it was about as popular as socks with sandals. People hated it. It lasted one week before Gap went "Oops!" and brought back the old logo design.

This, folks, is what happens when you try too hard to make your logo shout your ideology (in this case, "Look how modern we are!") instead of just being a good logo.


The Twinings Tale: A Lesson in Logo Longevity


Let’s talk about Twinings, the British tea company with a logo that’s been around since 1787. That’s right, over 230 years! Twinings has managed to keep its logo virtually unchanged, and there’s a reason for that. Their logo is a symbol of tradition, quality, and reliability – all key attributes for a tea brand.

Now, imagine if Twinings decided to modernize their logo drastically. Say they swapped their classic serif font for a sleek, minimalist design. While it might look trendy, it could alienate their loyal customer base who associate the old logo with the brand’s heritage and trustworthiness. The new logo might not resonate with the same sense of history and quality, potentially confusing customers and diluting the brand’s identity.



The Secret Sauce: Let Your Audience Do the Heavy Lifting

So, what's a brand to do? Here's a wild idea: create a logo that's like a Rorschach test. Let people see what they want to see. Why? Because:


1.    People love feeling like they're in on the secret

2.    A flexible logo speaks to more people (cha-ching!)

3.    You won't have to redesign every time the wind changes

4.    Customers feel like they're part of your brand's story

5.    Your logo can grow and change with you, no sweat

Wrapping It Up: The Logo Lowdown

At the end of the day, your logo is like your brand's handshake. It should be firm, memorable, but not trying to arm-wrestle everyone it meets. The best logos out there? They're the ones that wink at you, invite you in, but let you decide what they mean to you.

So next time you're cooking up a logo, remember: keep it simple, keep it flexible, and for the love of all things holy, don't try to cram your manifesto into it. Your future self (and your customers) will thank you.

Now, go forth and logo responsibly!

Source:

  1. https://hbr.org/2019/09/a-study-of-597-logos-shows-which-kind-is-most-effective
  2. https://www.theguardian.com/media/2010/oct/12/gap-logo-redesign
  3. https://twinings.co.uk/blogs/news/history-of-twinings
  4. https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-11517129
  5. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-83229-2_2